|
|
|
|
|
|
|

|
| Why are more children
being diagnosed with Autism? |
|
| |
A study
commissioned by the California
State Legislature and
conducted by the M.I.N.D.
Institute (UC-Davis) was
recently released on the
website of the California
Department of Developmental
Services. This study reports
that the number of individuals
being diagnosed with an
Autism Spectrum Disorder
(ASD) has increased exponentially
in recent years in California.
It is not known whether
there is a true increase
in the prevalence of Autism
or whether increased recognition
of the disorder and improved
diagnostic tools are providing
more accurate estimates
of the number of affected
persons. To leave this
question to the side for
a moment, there is no
debate about the impact
of more persons being
diagnosed with an ASD.
More afflicted individuals
means that more resources
are needed to provide
appropriate services.
There are already more
children with ASD who
need effective, validated
treatment delivered by
qualified providers than
there are individuals
receiving such services.
It is likely the case
that Autism had been severely
underdiagnosed until recently.
Second, prevalence(1)
estimates range greatly
depending on the criteria
used for assessing the
presence of an Autism
Spectrum Disorder. Wing
and Potter noted that
estimates as high or higher
than 6 per 1,000 have
been obtained in large
scale studies for ASD.
This is much higher than
the earliest estimates
of the prevalence of Autism
as 2-4 per 10,000. Wing
and Potter state that
they feel that the increased
prevalence is due to increased
awareness of the disorder
by the population at large
as well as by physicians
and other providers of
service to children and
better diagnostic tools
that more accurately covers
all of the Autism Spectrum.
They also acknowledge
that a true increase in
prevalence cannot be ruled
out and further research
is needed to determine
whether there is a true
increase in the prevalence
of Autism.
It does seem unlikely
that any increase in the
prevalence of Autism is
due to the measles-mumps-rubella
vaccine. Four studies
(Taylor et al., 1999;
Powell et al., 2000; Kaye
et al., 2001; and Dales
et al., 2001) conducted
to respond to the suggestion
that the MMR vaccine was
related to autism, each
found that the incidence(2)
of Autism rose on a yearly
basis prior to and after
the introduction of MMR.
This was taken by each
of these groups to emphatically
assert that MMR was unrelated
to Autism because if it
was, a sharper rise in
incidence should have
followed the introduction
of MMR, and this was not
observed.
Given the information
outlined above, I would
suggest that we do not
have enough information
to determine whether we
currently have accurate
estimates of the prevalence
and incidence of Autism.
There are a number of
researchers around the
country looking at determining
accurate measures of the
prevalence and incidence
of Autism. In future research
letters we will be reporting
on the results of these
studies. Regardless of
the answer to this question,
much time and energy will
have to be focused on
how to improve access
to effective services
for people with Autism.
|
| |
| |
1 - The term
prevalence refers
to the number of
individuals in a
particular population
who are afflicted
with the condition
being investigated.
(Wing & Potter,
2002)
2 - The term incidence
refers to the number
of individuals in
a specified population
in whom the condition
being studied begins
within a specified
time period (e.g.,
a calendar year).
(Wing & Potter,
2002)
|
| |
Dales, L. et al. (2001).
Time trends in autism
and in MMR immunization
coverage in California.
Journal of the American
Medical Association,
285, 1183-1185.
Kaye, J.A. et al.
(2001). Mumps, measles,
and rubella vaccine
and incidence of autism
recorded by general
practitioners: A time-trend
analysis. British
Medical Journal,
322, 460-463.
Powell et al. (2000).
Changes in the incidence
of childhood autism
and other autistic
spectrum disorders
in preschool children
from two areas of
the West Midlands.
Developmental
Medicine and Child
Neurology, 42,
624-628.
Taylor, B. et al.
(1999). Autism
and measles, mumps
and rubella vaccine:
No epidemiological
evidence for a causal
association.
Lancet, 353, 2026-2029.
Wing, L. & Potter,
D. (2002). The epidemiology
of autistic spectrum
disorders: Is the
Prevalence rising?
Mental Retardation
and Developmental
Disabilities Research
Reviews, 8(3),
151-161.
|
|
|
|
| Back
to NECC Comments |
|
|
|
|
|
| |
| |
33 Turnpike Road, Southborough, Massachusetts, 01772-2108 | directions
|
Telephone: 508-481-1015 | Fax: 508-485-3421 | e-mail |
|
|